Justice Clarence Thomas is widely known for his notable silence during oral argument, a deliberate practice borne out of the notion that he can learn more about a case by listening than through talking. But, don't mistake for Justice Thomas' silence for indifference, for he holds some strong views on the elements of persuasive legal writing, which he reveals in this exchange at Harvard Law School. For example:
"What I tell my law clerks is that we write these so that they are accessible to regular people. That doesn't mean that there's no law in it. But there are simple ways to put important things in language that's accessible. As I say to them, the beauty, the genius is not to write a 5 cent idea in a ten dollar sentence. It's to put a ten dollar idea in a 5 cent sentence.
That's beauty. That's editing. That's writing."
Suffice it to say that I echo Justice Thomas' beliefs about how there is a certain beauty in simplicity. I only wish Justice Thomas would speak more about the subject. Like Judge Kozinski, he has a lot to share on the topic of written advocacy.
Hat to Legal Writing Prof.
Thanks for sharing this wonderful post with us. I enjoyed the details that you provide in each of your articles. Have a great rest of your day.
ReplyDeleteGreg Prosmushkin
My public Defender lied to me saying there was never a smaller plea on the table long story, I just wanted the results from a so called residue for cocaine. The police would not let me see whatever they think was found in car and also. IT should all be in the minutes . I FEEL I WAS COHURSE D INTO MY PLEA AND HAVE NOT DONE DRUGS IN YEARS GO TO DOCTOR AND GET TESTED MONTHLY. WANTED TO GET THIS YEAR LONG PROBLEM OVER WITH BUT THE ORIGINAL PLEA WAS DISORDERLY CONDUCT BECAUSE THE POLICE WERE MAD AT ME 4 SOMETHING I DID THIRTEEN YEARS AGO ,SO I ASKED FOR LAB RESULTS BECAUSE I DO NOT DO COCAINE DONT TELL WHERE IT WAS FOUND IN TRUCK, I WAS SET UP JUST NEED TO KNOW IF I CAN APEAL IF I ALREADY PLEAD GUILTY BUT MY PUBLIC DEFENDER SHOWED ME NOT LAB RESULTS , OR DISCOVERY. IS THERE A WAY TO APPEAL. IVE HAD CLEAN RECORD FOR YEARS AND DONT NEED TO BE HARRASSED EVERY TIME MY WIFE GETS PULLED OVER.
ReplyDeletePlease get back to me.
ReplyDelete